Fundraiser Turnover and Legacy Giving: What the Data Says
Every fundraiser turnover stat you’ve read lately probably says 16 to 18 months. It gets repeated so often it’s treated as settled fact, but trace it back and you usually land on Penelope Burk’s 2013 book Donor-Centered Leadership. CompassPoint‘s UnderDeveloped study from the same year is often cited alongside it, but it reports vacancy lengths and planned departures, not average tenure. Both are now more than a decade old, and they were measuring a very different job market. Since then we’ve had a few wars, a global pandemic, many political and economic upheavals, and quite a few additional grey hairs – basically, the landscape is categorically different than in 2013. That’s important because it changes what you should actually be worried about.
If you run a legacy programme, that number was never really an HR statistic. It’s a pipeline risk statistic, and most organisations are treating it like the former.
The stat that should actually worry you
Here’s the one that matters more than tenure length: what happens in the gap. In CompassPoint’s 2013 data, the median vacancy in a development director role ran six months, and 46 percent of organisations with an open post reported vacancies longer than that. The consultancy CapDev estimates that donor trust then takes six to eighteen months to rebuild with a successor, depending on giving history. That is a practitioner estimate, not peer-reviewed evidence, so treat it as a planning assumption. For annual giving, that’s a rough patch. For legacy giving, where the ask horizon is already measured in years, a pause that long compounds against everything that came before it.
About that 16-to-18-month figure
In fairness, the picture is more complicated than the headline stat suggests. A 2022 national study of U.S. fundraisers by Shaker et al., published in a peer-reviewed journal, with 1,663 respondents, found a mean current job tenure of 3.6 years and a median of two years, with only 20 percent of fundraisers intending to leave their organisation and just 7 percent intending to leave the profession within the year. That’s a different story than the one circulating in most sector blog posts or conference presentations, although a median of two years is a reminder that the average hides a lot of short stays.
Does that mean the turnover concern is overblown? It isn’t, at least not for legacy giving. With a median current tenure of two years, most development staff won’t be in their seats long enough to see a legacy conversation through from first contact to a signed gift in will, a process that can run for years. The academic data softens the crisis narrative but it doesn’t erase the underlying problem for anyone doing relationship-based, multi-year fundraising.
Why legacy giving is more exposed than individual giving
Legacy conversations depend on repeated, personal contact over years, not a single well-timed ask. When the person holding that relationship leaves, the donor doesn’t automatically transfer their trust to whoever replaces them. They can sometimes quietly disengage. Legacy donors give because of a relationship and a belief in the mission, not because of a transaction, and a relationship is exactly what turnover breaks.
This isn’t unique to North America either: a 2024 UK report from Legacy Futures and Remember A Charity found that two-thirds of the legacy fundraisers surveyed (52 senior professionals) had been tempted away by a role at another charity, and just over half had moved because their organisation offered no career progression. It is the same pattern with a different 🇬🇧accent. The stakes are not small, either: the Chartered Institute of Fundraising’s 2026 benchmarking survey of 104 UK charities found that gifts in wills bring in 37 percent of voluntary income but receive only 15 percent of fundraising spend.
What’s actually driving the departures
Some of it is structural.
Boards often expect results far faster than relationship-based giving can deliver. Some of it is compensation, which nobody’s shocked by: salary had the largest effect of any variable tested in the Shaker et al. 2022 U.S. study, and 61 percent of the senior legacy fundraisers in the UK report said legacy professionals were leaving over salary dissatisfaction. But the reason worth sitting with is what Penelope Burk’s research at Cygnus Applied Research turned up: 40 percent of fundraisers left their last job over a “clash of culture,” which Burk described as conflicting opinions over how money should be raised. Yup, been there many times 😒That survey dates from 2013, so read it as a pattern, not a current rate. A gap between what boards expect and how relationship-based giving actually works isn’t a personality conflict. It’s a design flaw.
The fix isn’t retention perks
Better snacks and a wellness stipend won’t save a legacy pipeline. What helps is co-solicitation on your top legacy prospects so no single staff member is the only point of contact, documented stewardship history that survives a departure instead of living in one person’s head, a written legacy strategy with prospect rationale a successor can pick up mid-conversation, and executive involvement in legacy cultivation specifically, not just annual giving.
Most organizations don’t have a legacy giving problem. They have a continuity problem wearing a legacy giving costume, and turnover is what shows the cracks in the structure.
If your legacy pipeline currently depends on one person’s memory and one person’s relationships, that’s worth a conversation before the next resignation forces the issue. Legacy coaching is built for exactly this kind of continuity planning, so reach out if you’d like to talk it through.